Storytime! Scams to Watch Out for in NYC

Storytime! Scams to Watch Out for in NYC

Storytime! Scams to Watch Out for in NYC

New York City is such an exciting place to visit. The lights, the energy, the hustle and bustle. It’s truly one of a kind. However it's absolutely a place of all sorts of amazing scams and tricks, . Here’s what you need to know so you don’t get caught.


The Dodgy Mascot Performers

While wandering through Times Square, you’ll notice mascot performers who look unclean, cheap, and nasty. Think Minnie Mouse, but wearing old sneakers and smelling like garbage. These mascots beg you to take a photo with them.

After the photo is snapped, the mascot suddenly demands money. The tourist looks shocked and uncomfortable. They didn’t want a photo with this poor excuse for a mascot in the first place, let alone have to pay for it. But now the tourist feels stuck, like they have to hand over cash just to avoid drama.


Pickpockets in Busy Spots

In crowded places like subway stations and busy tourist spots, pickpockets are everywhere. I saw one guy bump into a tourist, acting all innocent and apologetic. While the tourist was distracted, another person skillfully reached into their bag.

It’s crazy how slick they are. They don’t even need to be obvious. Seeing this made me extra cautious with my own stuff. Keep your bag zipped, keep it close, and never put your wallet in your back pocket.


The “Struggling Artist” CD Scam

Another thing I saw near Central Park was someone pushing CDs on passersby. The guy claimed he was a struggling artist trying to make it big in the city. He convinced a few people to give him some money for a CD.

But here’s the catch: the CD was blank. Just a shiny disc with no music. Sometimes this scam comes with a partner too. While you’re distracted handing over cash, their friend might be eyeing your belongings for an easy grab. 


NYC is an ever evolving city, so while we didn't personally see these famous scams, they could absolutely still be around. 

1. The Friendship Bracelet Scam

A person, often sitting on a bench or near a tourist spot, will approach you offering to tie a friendship bracelet around your wrist “for free.” Once you let them, they’ll demand a high price and won’t take no for an answer.


2. The Petition Scam

Someone asks you to sign a petition for a cause or charity. Once you sign, they suddenly ask for a donation. Sometimes multiple people take turns pressuring you for money.


3. The Card or Shell Game

In busy areas like Times Square, you might see a “game” where someone bets you can guess which card or shell hides an object. It’s rigged, and you’ll almost always lose your money if you play.


4. Fake Charity Collectors

People with clipboards or collection buckets claim to raise money for well-known charities or disaster relief. Often, they are not affiliated with any legitimate organization.


5. Overpriced “Taxi” or “Tour” Scams

Unlicensed taxi drivers or unofficial tour guides will offer rides or tours at inflated prices. They may take longer routes or drop you off far from your destination.


6. The Gold Ring Trick

Someone “finds” a gold ring on the ground and offers to sell it to you for cheap. It’s either fake or they expect you to pay more once you express interest.

What I Learned Watching These Scams

  • Trust your gut. If something feels off, walk away.

  • Keep your valuables zipped and close to your body.

  • Don’t get roped into photos or buying stuff from street vendors you don’t trust.

  • Watch your surroundings in crowded places—pickpockets are patient and clever.


NYC is an incredible city. Don’t let these scammers spoil your trip. Stay aware, keep your wits about you, and enjoy the city safely. Have you seen any scams like these? Share your stories below—I’m all ears!

Back to blog

Leave a comment